Tags
As I have worked on my ficus bonsai this summer, I have been considering a question. Who do we learn from? For a number of years I felt pretty good about learning about how to care for tropicals from folks who have lots of experience, but those experienced folks I’ve been learning from are bonsai practitioners who live in subtropical areas like Florida.

The approach I have been following for a number of years has been to do heavy work on ficus mid-summer including defoliating for easy wiring and styling, and I repot then as well when necessary.
I really started questioning these practices when I listened to a recent podcast from Bonsai Mirai. The Asymmetry interview with David Cutchin addressed how some of the habits of Florida bonsai practitioners may not be such a great thing for their trees even in Florida where tropical species are suited to the climate. Specifically, the regular practice of defoliating was called out.
Extra problematic, then, is those of us who live in more Northerly locations learning from and copying those practices that seem to work well in Florida.

I am in Northern Virginia, and for my tropical trees mid-summer is when they have just started to show renewed vigor after recovering from six months inside. Cutchin suggests that regular defoliation is really hard on the continuing vigor of the trees. If that’s true in Florida, the lost vigor is especially worrisome to me when the trees can only enjoy being outside half the year and struggle to maintain vigor anyway.

Nevertheless, I wonder if and suspect that applying this technique might help to balance energy in the tree. The image above shows the significant range of leaf size that was cut from the tree during its recent defoliation. These range from a half inch to three inches. But if I suspect encouraging a full set of new leaves might help to balance the growth of the tree might some pruning or just a partial defoliation possibly do the same?

One way or another, it’s a bit late for this specimen, but I decided to try different approaches with some of my other tropicals. A couple trees that have been defoliated annually for the last few years have just been pruned without defoliation this year to see if it makes a difference in the vigor and growth of the trees. The experiment is not very scientific since tree growth varies from year to year, but if all I am doing by defoliating is slowing down the growth and development of my bonsai, I am all for trying something different.

In the meantime I will enjoy watching this tree fill back in with a brand new set of leaves.








